Dystopias Are Necessary Escape Fantasies

Dystopian stories (even when they’re quite nuanced like The Last of Us) allow us to escape—for a while—the boredom, the complexity, and the creeping dread of contemporary life. For 45 minutes or so, we get to imagine what it would be like to burn it all down and start over again. It’s a controlled burn—much like the experience of catharsis Aristotle described in the context of Greek tragedy, watching (for example) the Bacchae tear Pentheus to pieces with their bare hands. It lets us expend pent-up emotional energy and return (a little less anxious, maybe) to the concerns and complications of our 21st century lives.

Read More

That Great, Big Book about Bad, Old New York

Some readers have pointed out that Garth Risk Hallberg's City on Fire could have been more tightly edited. Maybe so. I didn't have the sense, while reading it, that whole sections were crying out to be lopped off, but it's entirely possible that a tougher editor than me could find more fat to trim. The thing is, this book wants to be a sprawling, kaleidoscopic rollercoaster ride through a vanished cultural landscape — that of dirty, old 1970s New York City from before Rudy Giuliani shipped all the homeless people off somewhere and replaced the Times Square porn shops with a 50-foot-high painting of Cat in the Hat. It wants to be grand, unwieldy, immersive. It wants to sweep you up and shake you around for a while before letting you go.

Read More